Examining the Bible: Genesis, Part I

For those who followed me on Xanga, I apologize.  I’m migrating my favorite posts over here.

The Christian story of the “fall of man” is a tale of magnificent power, poor decision-making skills, cunning linguists, and problems…lots and lots of problems.  I’ll give you the ones that immediately spring to mind.  This takes into account the literature from the Bible in Genesis 1:26-31Genesis 2, and Genesis 3:1-19.

Adam and Eve
"So, you come here often?"

Problem #1: Ignorance
God creates human beings with free will — although he never gave us a choice as to whether or not we wanted free will or even to be created at all.  As I’ve heard Christopher Hitchens say, “Of course we have free will; we have no choice!”  What god does not create humans with is the knowledge of good and evil — that is to say, they had no sense of right and wrong and no way to tell if disobedience was a sin — or even what “disobedience” or “sin” were.  I doubt their vocabulary included such complex words.  They were said to be completely innocent.

Problem #2: Temptation
God creates the “Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil” (sounds like a metaphor, right?) right smack dab in the middle of the ignorant human beings’ living space.  This tree produces delicious-looking, aromatic fruit (not apples though, they’re more like “knowledgeberries”) so – of course – god tells the humans not to touch it.  In fact, it would probably be best if they didn’t even look at it.  Perhaps just forget it’s even there…even though it’s in your living room.  Oh, and it’ll kill you.

Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil
That's a scary tree!

Problem #3: Clarity
God instructs the humans not to eat the fruit and tells them that the day they eat the fruit they’ll die, right then and there.  He didn’t give them a definition of “die” and from everything I’ve heard, the humans at this point had no experience whatsoever with death because everything was perfect in the Garden and nobody ate meat…not even the meat-eating predators.  One could argue that telling someone who has never seen or heard of death that they’re going to die doesn’t really have the impact that you’d expect.  Anyway (SPOILER ALERT), the point is we’ll see later that god bent the truth on this one because the humans didn’t die the same day they ate the fruit and, in fact, lived on to bear many children.

Problem #4: Outside Influence
God creates a talking, ambiguous serpent and sets it loose in the Garden, fully aware that the paths of the humans and this serpent would cross and that the serpent was a tricky little guy who derived pleasure from messing with people’s heads (or at least, it would seem).  Now, one could argue that setting up a scenario like this is a test.  I would argue that this scenario is nothing short of a masterful chef’s no-bake recipe for disaster.  Either way, it displays a woeful lack of foresight on god’s part.

The talking serpent convinces the woman (oh, of course it’s the woman because they’re weaker than men, right?) to just have a taste of the knowledgeberries because she’s most likely misinterpreting what god is saying and should actually be listening to what his words mean.  Now, I don’t know how things worked in the Garden but if I were confronted with an eloquently-spoken Gecko accosting me with persuasive arguments, I’d be inclined to buy his insurance.

Problem #5: Non-intervention
Anyway, the woman exercises her (coerced) free will by eating the fruit and convinces the man that he also misinterpreted what god meant so he eats it as well.  God is chilling somewhere else at this point.  Maybe he was in the shower or something.  Of course when god gets back and finds out (didn’t he already know?) he damns them and all of their descendants for all time.  That includes you, bub.

Adam and Eve Expelled
Expelled!

Conclusion
What have we learned from this story?  It’s best not to make decisions on an empty stomach, right?  No.  We’ve learned that god is a sadist who intentionally created humans ignorant so that he could have the pleasure of damning them forever after laughing at their decision to save 30% or more on car insurance (they didn’t even own a car!).

Now, the creation myth is said to be allegorical by some and literal by others but no matter how you slice it, it’s got problems from a moral standpoint.

For one, god gives humans free will but keeps them completely ignorant of right and wrong and therefore the consequences of their actions.  That’s pretty bad.  To make things worse, he puts the innocent-looking device that will cause their destruction within their arms’ reach.  That’s horrible.  Let’s not stop there though, because we haven’t yet introduced the cunning serpent who gets created with the powers of speech and convinces the humans (who don’t know right from wrong) that it’s OK to set the doomsday device off.  That’s detestable!  But wait, there’s more!  Next we’re going to damn the humans for making a choice that was a product of their god-given free will combined with their god-induced ignorance.  That’s disgusting!  Don’t stop there, though.  While we’re damning people we may as well extend the punishment out for eternity, applicable to every descendant of the humans without exception.  That’s just pure, unfettered evil.

Related

%d bloggers like this: